Marvel Studios has once again proven its prowess in reshaping the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) with the second season of “What If…?”. Peggy Carter, portrayed by Hayley Atwell, has emerged as a central figure in this animated anthology series, leaving an indelible mark on the fabric of the MCU. In Season 2 Episode 5, titled “Captain Carter Fought the Hydra Stomper,” the narrative takes a surprising twist, unveiling the profound impact of Captain Carter on the entire MCU timeline.
Peggy Carter’s transformation into Captain Carter in Season 1 was just the beginning. The recent episode reframes key events from “The Avengers” and “Captain America: The Winter Soldier” through Peggy’s unique perspective, providing a fresh lens through which fans can view the MCU’s rich tapestry.
One of the subtle yet game-changing revelations in this episode is the presence of Hope Van Dyne, the Wasp, in the Battle of New York. Executive producer A.C. Bradley confirmed on Twitter that Captain Carter’s existence paved the way for Hope’s early involvement with the Avengers, altering the team’s dynamics significantly.
Bradley went on to explain that Peggy’s victory in World War II triggered an immediate feminist movement, reshaping society and leading to more female S.H.I.E.L.D. agents, heroes, and women in positions of authority. This ripple effect expanded beyond the battlefield, reaching deep into the foundations of the MCU.
In the absence of Peggy Carter, who was missing for 70 years in her Captain Carter guise, key roles within S.H.I.E.L.D. were assumed by Howard Stark, Bucky Barnes, and the parents of Hope Van Dyne, Hank Pym, and Janet Van Dyne. Janet, the original Wasp, passed the mantle to her daughter, setting the stage for Hope’s involvement in the Battle of New York and her subsequent role as an Avenger.
The consequences of Captain Carter’s alternate timeline extend beyond gender dynamics. Bucky Barnes, freed from becoming the Winter Soldier, assumes a role reminiscent of Jimmy Carter, becoming an elder statesman. This twist in Bucky’s fate not only contributes to his happy ending but also saves Howard Stark from an early demise. Bradley notes that Howard, now a better father, shares a closer relationship with his son, creating a heartwarming ripple effect.
The meticulous attention to detail in exploring the ramifications of Peggy’s universe makes her timeline one of the most intriguing in the “What If…?” series. The creators, led by A.C. Bradley, showcase a deep appreciation for this alternate reality, leaving the door open for further exploration in future “What If…?” installments.
While “What If…?” Season 2 continues to unfold on Disney+, the captivating narrative of Captain Carter’s multiverse journey sparks hope for potential live-action adaptations. Hayley Atwell’s enthusiasm for reprising the role, coupled with the wealth of untold stories within this radically different universe, hints at exciting possibilities for the future of Peggy Carter in the MCU.